Happy Father’s Day to Keith Tkachuk, Brady Tkachuk is a Florida Panther. It turns out the years of speculation that the Ottawa Senators captain would one day leave for an American team were true, and perhaps we should have known all along it would be to join brother Matthew in the Sunshine State.
Tkachuk reportedly submitted a list of four teams — Carolina, Florida, Minnesota, and Vegas — but South Florida was always his preferred destination, so GM Steve Staios did the best he could with the situation. In the end, the Senators received three first-round picks (Nos. 9 and 25 in 2026, plus a 2029 first-rounder) and a 2027 second-round pick to send the superstar winger to his desired destination.
On the surface, it looks like the Panthers simply pried the captain and face of the franchise away from a division rival for future assets that, quite frankly, GM Bill Zito doesn’t care much about. That may very well be the case, but there’s much more to this blockbuster deal, so let’s dive into some trade grades and analysis for both teams.
Florida Panthers: A
If you had somehow forgotten about or written off the Panthers after missing the playoffs in 2025-26, this is a reminder that the Eastern Conference — and really the NHL as a whole — still runs through Florida.
The Panthers were already going to be extremely dangerous even without making a move of this magnitude. Essentially the same core that won back-to-back Stanley Cups is returning healthy, rested, and recovered. Now add Tkachuk into the mix without subtracting anything of significance from the roster. It almost feels unfair.
Three first-round picks are nothing to sneeze at, but for this Florida team and its current window, surrendering them for one of — if not the — best power forwards in hockey was a no-brainer.
Tkachuk fits the Panthers to an absolute tee and rounds out a forward group that will be a nightmare for the rest of the league to deal with.
We’ve already seen the chaos the Tkachuk brothers can cause together for Team USA at the 4 Nations Face-Off and the Olympics. Now that pairing becomes a reality in Florida. Put Sam Bennett between them and good luck to the opposition — you’re going to be in for a long night.
The only reason Zito doesn’t get an A+ is because three first-round picks and a second-rounder are, as mentioned, far from nothing. That said, we’re really nitpicking, because what the Panthers just pulled off is about as close to a perfect trade as you’ll see given the circumstances.
Ottawa Senators: B / To Be Determined
As painful as it is to trade Tkachuk within the Atlantic Division to an already loaded Florida team for future assets, Ottawa had to bite the bullet and move forward.
If the Senators simply use this return to replenish their prospect pool, then fine, they may eventually get some quality and quantity back. But this team isn’t in a position to wait three to five years for those draft picks to potentially make an impact at the NHL level.
Tim Stutzle is 24, and Jake Sanderson soon will be as well. Ottawa wants and has to compete over the next three to five years while those players are under contract and in their primes.
As a result, there’s already been talk of Staios using some of this draft capital to acquire an impact player who can help the team win now, and how — or whether — he’s able to do that will greatly affect how this trade is viewed.
The dream acquisition? Jason Robertson. An equally impactful superstar winger who has consistently been even more productive offensively than Tkachuk would represent a tremendous pivot. It would cost plenty both in a trade and on a contract extension, but the Senators are well-equipped to make it happen.
The big question — and potential sticking point — is whether Robertson would have any interest in coming to the nation’s capital.
Not a great sign. But if Ottawa somehow pulls it off, the Tkachuk trade suddenly becomes an A, and a win-win for both sides.
While Robertson would be the ideal replacement, there are several fallback options that could move this deal into B+ territory.
Veteran Pittsburgh Penguins wingers Rickard Rakell and Bryan Rust once again appear to be available and are intriguing options. Jordan Kyrou’s time in St. Louis feels all but over, and we’ve heard the Senators connected to him before. What about another intra-division deal, this time with the rival Toronto Maple Leafs for Matthew Knies — a younger version of Tkachuk?
Those are all possibilities worth monitoring, but one somewhat under-the-radar option that we love is JJ Peterka. It hasn’t even been a full year since he was traded to the Utah Mammoth, but could an underwhelming first season and limited playoff ice time mean he’s no lock to stay?
He and Stutzle have shown tremendous chemistry together internationally for Team Germany.
Would it be a move that carries some risk? Sure. But it also comes with significant upside. Peterka is only 24 years old, fits perfectly with Ottawa’s timeline, and posted 68 points (27 goals, 41 assists) in 2024-25. Not to mention the acquisition cost shouldn’t be outrageous, potentially allowing the Senators to make multiple additions in replacing Tkachuk.
It’s hard to take much positive from the way Tkachuk’s tenure in Ottawa came to an end, but Staios and company still have an opportunity to make the best of it, and it’ll be fascinating to see whether they can do that.
Next: Predicting Where the NHL’s Top Offseason Trade Candidates Will Land
Leave a Reply